The Alliance of Boulder County
on Tobacco and Health

Boards of Health as Venues for Clean Indoor Air Policy Making

A new paper has just been published in American Journal of Public Health about the tobacco industry's responses to board of health initiatives about tobacco:

Boards of Health as Venues for Clean Indoor Air Policy Making Joanna V. Dearlove, BA and Stanton A. Glantz, PhD

Objectives. This study sought to determine the tobacco industry's strategies for opposing health board actions and to identify elements necessary for public health to prevail.

Methods. Newspaper articles, personal interviews, and tobacco industry documents released through litigation were reviewed.

Results. Twenty-five instances in which the tobacco industry opposed health board regulations were identified. It was shown that the tobacco industry uses 3 strategies against health boards: "accommodation" (tobacco industry public relations campaigns to accommodate smokers in public places), legislative intervention, and litigation.

These strategies are often executed with the help of tobacco industry front groups or allies in the hospitality industry.

Conclusions. Although many tobacco control advocates believe that passing health board regulations is easier than the legislative route, this is generally not the case.

The industry will often attempt to involve the legislature in fighting the regulations, forcing advocates to fight a battle on 2 fronts.

It is important for health boards to verify their authority over smoking restrictions and refrain from considering nonhealth factors (including industry claims of adverse economic impacts) so as to withstand court challenges.

The full paper is on the web at"

The authors are with the Institute for Health Policy Studies, Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco.

Correspondence: Requests for reprints should be sent to Stanton A. Glantz, PhD, Box 0130, University of California, San Francisco, CA 94143-0130 (e-mail:

Return to the Tobacco as a Problem for Nonsmokers home page.
Return to the Alliancehome page.
URL of this page: