US Election Assistance Commission - Voluntary Voting System Guidelines Vote
EAC Home
Introduction
View Guidelines
View Comments
Glossary

View Comments

Section CommentsGeneral CommentsGlossary Comments
 
Name :   Leslie Simmons
Organization :   ACLU of Northern California
Post Date :   9/29/2005

Section Comments
Section :  6.8
Page no. :  
Line no.:  
Comment :  The California Election Protection Network, a non-partisan organization of over 25 groups coming together to achieve their mutual election integrity goals, requests that Section 6.8 be amended to require the following:

Gold Star Audit Protocol (in honor of those who have given their lives in the name of democracy) All state elections shall have (at State’s expense):

• PAPER BALLOTS: Accessible, voter-verifiable, individual paper ballots on archival paper (that can be kept for years as proof the election result).  

• HAND COUNTS: A manual audit which relies on human eyes.

• STATISTICALLY SIGNIFICANT SAMPLING: Select a minimum of 5% of all precincts (and precincts cannot exceed 1000 voters). Within these selected precincts, audit 100% of the paper ballots; or in their absence, the paper trails.

• GENUINELY RANDOM: Genuinely random selected samples (not at the discretion of by election officials).

• PUBLIC OVERSIGHT: Each political participating political party may form delegations to witness every step of the election process. Results of each tally posted publicly on a public-accessible posting at the precinct site, as well as on a public-accessible portion of the Secretary of State's website in a comma-delimited format (e.g. a format that may easily be extracted into a word processing or spreadsheet software), BEFORE the data is transferred (e.g. to the county’s central tabulator).

• RECOURSE: Any discrepancies between the machine tally and the audit Gold Star audit protocol shall require the State to repeat this Gold Star Audit protocol; however, each time the sample size shall increase by 10%. The final result of this audit process supersedes the finding of the initial tally and is binding.